Had the competition continued, Ebenezer Smith would have faced the winner of Dearborn and Quick's duel, and the winner of Smith's duel would have faced Tomo Matsuzaka. The winner of that duel would then have faced the eighth-grade winner to decide the middle-grades champion, who would then have gone on to face the upper-grades champion to determine the Charmbridge Dueling Champion.
- Winner ~ Matsuzaka (grade-winner)
- Winner ~ Smith (technique)
- match canceled